To A Hammer, They All Look Like Nails

adweek/photos/stylus/23300-SocialL.jpgHere’s a vote for keeping people spaces, people spaces.

This interesting piece from AdWeek speaks to new findings about the underuse and ineffectiveness of advertising on Facebook and MySpace.  What’s really interesting is not that this is the case — after all, these are “people spaces” and not “product spaces” — but that the swing of the article suggests the communities should be adopting to being a better advertising environment.  Here’s another point of view: changing the environment will just chase people away to other, new places online where they can connect unfettered by advertisements.  Maybe the communities aren’t the ones who need to step up…maybe it’s the BRANDS that do.  If brands brought more useful content to social communities — telling people stories in people spaces — everybody wins.  Audiences get what they need and demand, brands get a whole new level of trust from their consumers, and the communities keep on being communities. 

Social Networking Traffic Up as Ads Fall Flat, per IDC

More than three-quarters of social networking site users log on at least once a week, and 57% do so daily

Nov 25, 2008

-By Mike Shields, Mediaweek

  NEW YORK More than half the country actively uses social networking sites, but so far advertising on these properties is nothing short of anemic, says a new report issued by market research firm IDC. In fact, IDC calls advertisers’ attempts to tap into these sites’ unique social nature “stillborn.”

According to IDC’s report “U.S. Consumer Online Attitudes Survey Results Part III,” more than three-quarters of social networking site users log on at least once a week, and 57 percent do so daily. And these folks are logging an increasingly large amount of time on these properties, as more than 61 percent of users spend more than a half hour on these sites per session, with 38 percent staying at least an hour.

Yet despite those huge usage numbers, social networking sites like MySpace and Facebook significantly underperform when compared to overall online advertising, per IDC. Just 57 percent of social net users report clicking on an ad over the past year versus 79 percent of all users, according to the study. A similar disparity is evident when it comes to online shopping.

“The thinking has been that the popularity of [social networking sites] will attract a big audience and generate a lot of traffic, which in turn will produce enormous amounts of user-generated content and therefore advertising inventory, without any expenses for editorial staff or content distribution deals,” said Karsten Weide, program director, digital marketplace: media and advertising, IDC. That’s all proven true, said Weide, except the advertising part. “[These sites] have had a hard time selling this inventory.”

Until recently, MySpace and Facebook have promised that as long as users provide information on their age, location, personal interests and the like — advertisers will be able to offer highly targeted ads. But IDG’s study found that only 3 percent of users surveyed are OK with publishers using their contact information for advertising. “That idea is stillborn,” says the report.

So what can social nets do to improve ad effectiveness?  Become more like portals, says IDC, and give users something to do other on these sites other than communicate. That’s something MySpace has gradually done over the past few years as it’s added more professionally produced content and video. 




    Track comments via RSS 2.0 feed. Feel free to post the comment, or trackback from your web site.

    Currently there are no comments related to article "To A Hammer, They All Look Like Nails".


We Are... BIG FUEL

Hello! Big Fuel is a full-service marketing and communications company based in New York that takes brands from Content To Commerce. A unique approach that bridges "people stories" to "product stories" through social media and branded content.

Big Fuel is one part marketing agency, building brands through consumer insight; one part entertainment company, creating content that people love; and one part distribution company, driving guaranteed results by delivering content to targeted audiences. We work with major brands, leading agencies, publishers and platforms to help marketers achieve true consumer engagement.

test Latest from Twitter
Watch Videos